Zwigoff gives plenty of time to Crumb’s critics, and the charges of sexism and racism are nicely counterbalanced by Australian art critic Robert Hughes (1938-2012), who compares Crumb to Breughel and Goya, and chastises America for being too preoccupied with political correctness to appreciate Crumb’s brand of wild satire and grotesque imagery. “What do you do with practically anybody who’s got a vision of the world which isn’t in accord with the present standards at Berkeley?” says Hughes. Indeed, the movie’s end finds Crumb moving to France, as if squeezed out by an increasingly intolerant homeland. But the man will never be stopped. The movie’s elegant intro, where Zwigoff pans across a collection of empty thread spools, each adorned by a tiny Crumb sketch, shows that Crumb draws the way other people breathe, and will continue to draw until there’s no life in his body. The chastising talking heads and baffled ex-girlfriends are simply no match for him.
Crumb was such a success that it inspired other filmmakers to seek out their own Crumbs. Chris Smith found his in Mark Borchardt, a bumbling Wisconsin filmmaker trying to finish a movie called Northwestern, a magnum opus about “rust and decay.” In American Movie (1999), also showing on Crackle, we see the true meaning of “indy filmmaking,” as Borchardt, an angry 30-year-old with a chip on his shoulder and a drinking problem, fights gallantly to finish Coven, a short horror film which he hopes will make enough money to finance Northwestern. He enlists his friends and family to help, including his cantankerous uncle Bill who loans him $3,000.00, and his buddy Mike Schank, a good-hearted ex-druggie who keeps the movie warm with his nervous laugh. When Borchardt accuses Mike of stealing a riff from a Black Sabbath song for the Coven soundtrack, Mike matter-of-factly reminds him that “ideas don’t just come out of thin air.”
American Movie and Crumb are two sides of the same coin. Robert Crumb and Mark Borchardt are both iconoclasts. Though his talent can’t compare to Crumb’s, Borchardt has a knack for framing scenes, and he knows what looks good in a movie. The real difference between them is that Crumb had an unbreakable faith in himself. Borchardt, as shown in American Movie, had some deep-rooted anger that went well beyond Crumb’s inability to get girls in high school. Mostly, Borchardt nurses a hatred of his own working class roots. His anger leads him to drink, which prevents him from getting his work done. That he actually finishes Coven and has a little premiere at a local theater feels more like a fluke than a triumph. Since appearing in American Movie, Borchardt has directed only one short. What American Movie did for him is turn him into a cultish figure; he has taken several bit parts in low budget films, and along with Schank appeared in cartoon form in a 2006 episode of Family Guy, an insider’s reference that is probably lost on most people by now.
American Movie won the Grand Jury prize at the Sundance Film Festival. So did Crumb, a few years earlier. Since that flourishing period of the American documentary, there’s been a decline, I think. Documentary filmmakers now go for either the overly silly, or the overly maudlin. Perhaps reflecting the current American culture, documentaries must be either goofy, or self-consciously “important.” Though the doc is even more marginalized than the small, indy film these days, the silly ones still have their audience, though in diminishing numbers. Yet, I’m always reminded of Harvey Pekar’s line in American Splendor, when his friend Toby is on MTV, and Pekar grouses that the corporate world thinks nothing of taking these salt-of-the-earth types and letting audiences laugh at them.
Certainly, there have been some good documentaries in recent years, but they tend to feel staged now, owing more to an episode of Real World than the non-fiction works of, say, Errol Morris or Werner Herzog. It’s been a long time since I’ve seen anything comparable to Crumb trying to maintain his flip demeanor when describing his father smashing his collarbone, or Mike Schank’s confiding to Chris Smith’s camera that he’d just won a few bucks on a scratch ticket and didn’t want anyone to know. Smith’s choice of Jerry Jeff Walker’s ‘Mr. Bojangles’ to play over the final credits, first on Schank’s acoustic guitar and then sung by Sammy Davis Jr., tells me American Movie, despite moments of unintentional comedy, was not a joke, but a serious musing on those who dream big but remain stuck somewhere, in a cell, in a job, in a cold hometown that seems to work against you at every turn.